If one were to judge based on the 2010 CES alone, it seems that smart phones have arrived overnight in the market.  With the introduction of a bevy of new Android models like the Nexus One, apps launching like crazy, and a media jiggy for everything smart phone, it’s as if suddenly everyone is jumping on the bandwagon. In fact, according to news reports, nearly half the handsets that will be purchased in the next six months in Canada will be smart phones.

Like many technology instant success stories, this one has been a long time in the making.  The first smart phones were conceived in the late 1990’s by Microsoft, Intel and Palm. Those phones came to market in 2001 (does anyone remember the HTC Orange SPV?).  BlackBerry phones hadn’t launched, nor any of the host of other competitors. 

The smart phone story is about like every other new technology introduction story that involves a consumer platform.  The proliferation of USB devices took about 8 years, from start to finish;  Universal Plug and Play became mostly universal in about 7 years;  Microsoft Windows, launched in 1983, didn’t really become ubiquitous until 1992 with the launch of Windows 3.1; the first OFDM Wireless LAN products were sold in the early 1990’s and finally branded WiFi in 1999.

These were all “big science” product launches.  They involved the creation of new technologies, the establishment of standards and ecosystems to support those new technologies, and the education of markets.  No mean feat, and not the stuff that start-ups typically focus on. Today’s start-up and start-up investors are far more likely to build an internet property, where momentum can be established quickly, investment levels are lower, and returns are faster. Dave McClure suggests in Startups & VCs: Learn How to Design, Market, & Eat Your Own Consumer Internet Dogfood, engineering is actually a secondary requirement for internet startups.  McClure says the key factor is user experience and product management – micro-launch, measure, repeat.

If you’re a founder, McClure’s words ought to make you pause.  McClure, and nearly all investors that I know of, favour businesses where early momentum is the game.  They’re cheap and quick to build, and the potential for success or failure can be gauged quickly without risking a lot of capital.

And if you’re building a platform based business, consider it a decade long project.  Also be aware that even if you’re first to market (as Microsoft and Palm were), that is no guarantee of success. Nimbler competitors may build upon your success while you are wedded to your first generation product and eco-system.

Food for thought. 


The title of Friday’s call was Small Computers vs. Big Phones, and the impetus was an issue of Mark Anderson’s Strategic News Service by the same name.  We talked about the coming “war” between smartphones and netbooks, computing in the cloud, and where the intersection between these devices might occur.

Many people expressed the opinion that we would likely be carrying multiple devices, depending on context, and thus were inclined to dismiss the idea that a war might be coming as hyperbole. 

Nevertheless, there’s certainly jockeying for position going on as TI prepares to ship 1W multi-core processors, operating system vendors duke it out, and the device manufacturers themselves battle for the hearts and minds of consumers. 

Friday’s conference call was recorded on Calliflower.  In attendance: Tim Panton, Carl Ford, Jonathan Greene, Brad Jones, Bill Volk, Jim Courtney, Doug Renert, Kim Dushinski, Barlow Keener, Sheryl Breukrer, Ken Camp, Todd Spraggins, Sergio Meinardi, Misha Nossik, and Aga Magdolen.


Reblog this post [with Zemanta]


SquawkBox Feb 27: Small Computers vs. Big Phones – the Next War.

February 22, 2009

A few weeks ago, Mark Anderson’s excellent SNS newsletter (subscription only) carried a piece titled "Small Computers vs. Big Phones – the Next War". I thoroughly enjoyed it and thought at the time that it would make excellent SquawkBox fodder. The past few weeks have seen nVidia release sophisticated graphics processors for mobile phones, the […]

Read the full article →

Balsamiq Mockups earns a place in our toolkit.

January 6, 2009

Have you ever been in one of those design meetings where everyone gets hung up on colors, or button placement, rather than focusing on the fundamentals of how the product is supposed to work?  We all tend to obsess over the minutiae of the design rather than functionality, which is putting the cart before the […]

Read the full article →
Alec on LinkedIn Alec on Twitter Alec on Facebook Calliflower on Youtube RSS Feed Contact me