open source

Tilting at Open Source Windmills

by alec on May 18, 2011

Now that Microsoft has bought Skype, calls for the creation of an open source Skype Killer are starting to be heard.  They’re delusional.  There’s only one Skype, and only likely to be one Skype simply because the protocol is closed and the momentum behind Skype is enormous.  That’s why Microsoft bought them, instead of trying to make MSN Messenger into a Skype killer.

Richard Stallman himself is suggesting that many alternatives to Skype already exist.  He points to a list of GNU projects all built around SIP, which is the open standard that provides similar services to Skype.  SIP, however, has never achieved the ubiquity, or momentum in the market that Skype has. 

In a communications product, which depends on network effects for utility, momentum is everything.  It’s a virtuous circle – each new user brings a network of more new users.  Skype has the momentum, and nobody else does. 

Can you say “tilting at windmills”, children? I thought you could!

{ 0 comments }

Open Source licenses gain teeth

by alec on August 14, 2008

Lawrence Lessig

Image via Wikipedia

Lawrence Lessig reports that free software licenses have been upheld.  According to Lessig, the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has said that

CC licenses set conditions (rather than covenants) on the use of copyrighted work. When you violate the condition, the license disappears, meaning you’re simply a copyright infringer. This is the theory of the GPL and all CC licenses. Put precisely, whether or not they are also contracts, they are copyright licenses which expire if you fail to abide by the terms of the license.

The case in question has now been sent back to the District Court to determine whether there is grounds for an injunction to be granted to the plaintiff.

Although many businesses have treated Open Source code with respect for some time, this ruling adds teeth to Open Source licenses.  Violate the rights granted to you in an Open Source license, and you may land in court!  This should provide a tremendous boost to businesses like Protecode, who make tools for help track and manage the pedigree of code used by developers in their applications.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

{ 1 comment }

Squawk Box June 3

June 3, 2008

Today we started off with Craigslist’s decision to ban VoIP and prepaid cellular numbers from their system. We had Cory Andrews and Garrett Smith from VoIP Supply on the line to talk about it with us. Cory had written a blog post for the VoIP Supply Blog yesterday about this.

Generally there was sympathy for Craigslist, but consensus that the approach is too blunt an instrument.

We also tried to talk about Facebook Open Platform. Yesterday the API infrastructure, the FBML parser, the FQL parser, and FBJS, as well as implementations of many common methods and tags were released. However, there was little enthusiasm for this topic on the call.

Read the full article →

Squawk Box May 28

May 28, 2008

We started off with Facebook’s plan to open source the Facebook Platform. This is being characterized as a nearly inevitable response to OpenSocial. The claimed effect is to allow nearly any social network to become Facebook compatible, and to create a cross platform API for apps. Facebook will apparently opensource FBML, FQL, FJS, and the FB API.

The real question will be how is it licensed, who owns changes to the tools, and how is it administered.

Yesterday at the All Things D conference, Microsoft showed video of the new Windows Multi-touch interface. Unlike Apple’s multi-touch, it actually works on the screen — pinches, squeezes and so on on a tablet size device. We talked about whether it was as revolutionary as some people seemed to think, and how Apple might respond. And, we talked about the potential contradiction that was implied by Microsoft VP Steve Sinofsky’s tight lighted approach to Windows 7 communications.

A couple of people had installed the Nokia N95 V20 firmware update. People felt that it was faster, and had new features.

And finally, we chatted about the New York Times and their announcement of an API. The Times intent is to allow programmers to easily mash up the content with their applications. Nick Desbarats from Choicebot was on the line, and he was very clear that Choicebot would find the Times API valuable.

Read the full article →

WorxBox looks promising

February 11, 2007

WorxBox is … The Asterisk Server with the Worx®! The goal of the Worxbox® project is to provide a production quality Open-Source Unified Communications Server that’s easy to build, configure and manage. WorxBox® installs all the software needed to deploy a fully functional Asterisk® based PBX and creates a basic configuration which can then be [...]

Read the full article →

VoIP Magazine on MS Unified Communications

June 30, 2006

Bryan Richards, editor-in-chief of VoIP Magazine.com, has a go at Microsoft’s Unified Communications Strategy.  In main, he wonders about the value, writing: “It’s all very interesting technology but seems a bit much to make a phone call even if it is just to leave a voice mail.” and… “making a phone ring when someone is [...]

Read the full article →

Mail from Microsoft’s Kyle Marsh

June 29, 2006

A couple of days after I wrote Microsoft’s Unified Communications “Strategy”, I got a nice note from Kyle Marsh, unified communications evangelist. He gave some additional details about the products, as well as correcting a mistake I made. I understood that Exchange would be renamed Microsoft Communcations Server, which in fact is not the case. [...]

Read the full article →

Microsoft's Unified Communications "Strategy"

June 26, 2006

For the last week, I’ve been wondering what Microsoft would announce today, at their Microsoft Unified Communications Group Strategy Day (what a mouthful, eh?). You see, ever since Ina Fried wrote her piece titled Microsoft Aims to End “Phone Tag“ on News.com, people have been phoning me and asking what I thought of it. My guess [...]

Read the full article →

OCRI Partnership Series: Open Source and Business

June 14, 2006

My friend, Dr. Tamas Koplyay, is hosting a local conference on open source on June 23rd.  Titled Open Source Licenses and Business Opportunities, this conference is for decision-makers in industry and government who wish to know: how open source licenses and the pedigree of the code affect business opportunities, the structure of business transactions, and [...]

Read the full article →

Open Source and Business Issues

April 22, 2006

I was very pleased to be able to have a joint session with Tom Marlay of Gowlings on Open Source, and Business.  The session was well attended, and was a quick overview of open source issues.  For my part, I covered mostly the issues in this story which I wrote some time ago.  Tom covered [...]

Read the full article →
Alec on LinkedIn Alec on Twitter Alec on Facebook Calliflower on Youtube RSS Feed Contact me