Geist

Squawk Box June 19 with Michael Geist

by alec on June 19, 2008

Michael Geist

Image by yulbuzz via Flickr

The last few weeks have been terrible set backs for personal privacy, and the privileges ordinary people enjoy when they buy and use music, video and other forms of media.

Today’s guest was Dr. Michael Geist, an internationally recognized expert in these areas. We discussed Bill C-61 the Canadian copyright law tabled last week, as well as the Anti-Counterfeiting Trade Agreement leaked in late May which seeks to enable border searches of computers and music players, and require ISPs to cooperate to provide information about suspected copyright infringers without a warrant.

Michael gave us a brief overview of what the legislation is and how close it is to the DMCA.  Bill C-61, far from being a made in Canada solution, appears to be a clone of the worst parts of the DMCA, with all kinds of negative implications for consumers, and privacy. It has generated massive amounts of commentary here as a result.

We speculated that the reason for introducing the bill now was simply to let it lie over the summer and get it out of the public consciousness.

We also talked about ACTA, which is an international treaty designed to apply the same rules between countries.  Affecting the European Community, Australia, New Zealand, and North America, ACTA purportedly will have far reaching implications, including an enforcement group.  Michael cautioned, however, that the treaty is still not visible to the public, and counseled the government to engage in a more transparent process.

On the call: Michael Geist, Dan York, Jim Courtney, Craik Pyke, Dave Brown, Jeb Brilliant, James Body, Peter Childs, Randall Howard and Dale Gass.

Zemanta Pixie

{ 0 comments }

Geist vs Goldberg

by alec on March 18, 2008

Two of my favorite personalities on the Canadian web are Mark Goldberg and Michael Geist.  Often taking opposite positions on key issues, their commentary is always a worthwhile read.  So, this morning read Geist's cautionary piece on censorship and then read Goldberg's counter that reasonable societies should censor some elements of the web

I don't pretend to know the answers.  You'll have to make up your own minds.  But I have sympathy for both the argument that children need to be protected, and freedom of expression must be preserved.  As a society we need to preserve both of these values. 

Let's start by reframing the debate though.  Censorship is a dirty word.  It implies a restriction on the reasonable freedoms that citizens in a free society should have.  If we're going to have a conversation about preventing access to child porn, then let's frame the conversation in those terms, rather than talking about censorship. 

{ 1 comment }

Special Guest Michael Geist on Squawk Box Feb 1

January 31, 2008

We're going to have a minor celebrity on our call tomorrow in legal expert Michael Geist.  He'll be joining us to talk about the Canadian DMCA which will soon be before Parliament.  It's striking that our politicians are proposing such legislation now, given the acknowledged failure of American efforts.  In any case, it promises to [...]

Read the full article →

Geist on Internet Surveillance

October 31, 2006

Michael Geist’s column in the paper this morning highlights how government is attempting to re-introduce internet surveillance legislation by splitting opposition from privacy advocates and civil society advocates.  His blog entry covers the same ground as the paper, so if you can’t read the Toronto Star, or Ottawa Citizen, you can read his point of [...]

Read the full article →
Alec on LinkedIn Alec on Twitter Alec on Facebook Calliflower on Youtube RSS Feed Contact me