bluetooth

100% hands-free is a challenge

by alec on June 5, 2009

In April of this year the Ontario Government passed hands-free legislation.  It is likely to go into effect some time this fall, and when it does all forms of handheld devices that can be used in a car will be banned – this includes GPS receivers, satellite receivers, iPods and other gadgets. Penalties will be stiff, including fines of up to $1,000 and up to six demerit points.

Recently I’ve been using the Contour Design SurfaceSound Compact Bluetooth Speaker in my vehicle.  This speaker clips to the visor above the driver. The microphone is on a small swing down arm, which also activates the bluetooth radio.  When receiving a call, you simply swing the arm down.  In a second or so the bluetooth connection is made, and you are able to speak.  When finished the call, swing the arm back, and the unit turns off.

The battery life is outstanding when used as I described.  Since last November, when I acquired the SurfaceSound Compact, I have charged twice. That’s right – two times.

Sound quality is also good.  The 2”x3” speaker allows good volume and reasonable quality audio.  With a little practice, the microphone arm is easily placed where you can be heard, without interfering with your driving.

The biggest challenge is in placing a call.  iPhone makes this very difficult because it has no support for voice dialing – a major omission.  There are a number of aftermarket voice dial applications available.  Say Who Dialer works well.  You can either speak the name of a contact, or speak a phone number.  Say Who then dials the intended recipient.  With a large address book like mine (nearly 5,000 contacts) it’s reasonably accurate, but most of the time I find myself simply speaking the number for the recipient.  It’s much faster and more convenient than looking the number up on the iPhone.

Nevertheless, even with Say Who Dialer, it’s impossible to meet the requirements of the Ontario legislation when placing a call.

  • The application must be started, which means picking up the iPhone, finding the application on the springboard, and starting it.
  • Once started, the voice recognition is started by pressing a large colored button on the screen, and speaking into the iPhone microphone. You cannot simply speak to the bluetooth microphone, because that microphone isn’t activated until the dialer is invoked.

Until such time as Apple provides a proper voice dialer, the SurfaceSound Compact is a great solution for receiving a call with iPhone.  To place a call legally, however, it seems the only way to do so will be to bring the vehicle to a stop.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

{ 6 comments }

David SparkDavid Spark (subbing in for Alec Saunders) here of The Spark Minute subbing in for Alec Saunders today on the Squawk Box.  My guest on today’s show was Andrew Eisner of Retrevo, the consumer electronics search engine. I asked Andrew to come on and discuss his extremely popular article, “Seven reasons why the new iPhone sucks” and how Retrevo finds and indexes all content online about consumer electronics. We also got to talking about iPhone applications as well and if Apple’s walled garden approach is better or worse than the carrier’s walled garden approach.

Other topics in this show include the insane volume of High Def coverage that will be at the Olympics, the good and bad with Bluetooth and wired headsets.

Sony's bluetooth lav microphone

May 3, 2007

Seth Godin asks for a bluetooth lavaliere microphone.  May I introduce you to the Sony ECM-HW1, Seth? The silvery grey piece on the left is the microphone, and the grey block on the right is the receiver. It's a little bulky, yes, but can be clipped to your lapel, strapped to an arm band, or hung around your [...]

Read the full article →

Plantronics Releases VoIP Optimized Bluetooth Headset

May 17, 2006

Plantronics just announced a new bluetooth VoIP headset for PC based softphone applications.  The kicker? Voyager 510-USB features multipoint technology to allow users to switch between multiple Bluetooth-enabled devices, including softphones and mobile phones, with the touch of a button.   I was just discussing this very issue over lunch yesterday.  The fact that my bluetooth [...]

Read the full article →

The Search for Cool Apps

September 27, 2005

Telephony Online published a write-up of the VON Panel "The Search for Cool Apps".  This is perhaps one of the most unfortunate panels at the show.  Forever consigned to the last day of the show (this year, the last session of the show), and populated with speakers who aren’t applications people, I think this might [...]

Read the full article →

Blackberry 7290

February 7, 2005

I retired the Motorola MPx200 last week.  As much as I loved this phone, the radio was an 1800/1900 unit, and completely impractical in Ottawa.  Reception was always spotty, and battery minimal as the poor thing valiantly tried to keep a signal alive by increasing the gain on the radio. I replaced it with a [...]

Read the full article →
Alec on LinkedIn Alec on Twitter Alec on Facebook Calliflower on Youtube RSS Feed Contact me