≡ Menu

Me different? Not really.

I’m going to paraphrase Andy Abramson, because his analysis, although thorough, is also darn long.  Andy has combined two of the big stories of the last week — the rumoured Skype killer under development by a consortium of carriers, and the Clearwire / Sprint Wimax announcement — and concluded that it’s really the latter who have the opportunity (in conjunction with their cable partners) to build a strong competitor to Skype.  Moreover, with this next gen WiMax network, they might also be able to drive a nail through the hearts of the incumbents.

Hrrrmmm.  I guess I’m in the Ken Camp camp on this one. It’s too damn late.  Expecting these folks to really get it together and figure out how to do this is … a stretch.  There’ll be be kosher pork at the grocery before something this unlikely happens.

Besides, to borrow from Andy, this is a me-also play, not a me different.  WiMax is fast (max 70 Mb/s), but not a lot faster than HSPA (42 Mb/s down, 11.5 Mb/s up).  Because it’s symmetrical, WiMax is well suited to backbone applications, but really doesn’t confer a lot of benefit on the end point.

So video calling?  Sure.  But you can do the same on HSPA. 500kb/s required — not 11.5 Mb/s. And carriers like Rogers are already doing it.

No, to really really change the game would require a leap of imagination that I don’t think Clearwire / Sprint possesses.  WiMax is symmetrical high speed.  Imagine a pure peer sharing network instead. Something like the TerraNet system — Skype style p2p for communications, and bittorrent style p2p for content distribution. Mesh it so you don’t have to build out a massive infrastructure.  Price the whole thing at a flat rate for access only, and sit back and watch the destruction of 125 years of legacy telecom.

That’s a me different.  That’s a game changer.  And it’s something that no carrier or content provider has the cojones to execute on.

{ 1 comment… add one }

  • Roland Tanglao May 19, 2008, 2:35 am

    “Price the whole thing at a flat rate for access only, and sit back and watch the destruction of 125 years of legacy telecom.” – Amen, brother!

Leave a Comment