Saturday, November 29, 2003

Cosh on Spencer

by alec on November 29, 2003

A few more links on the Larry Spencer affair, mostly responding to Colby Cosh’s Friday post

Casting the first stone? points out that Spencer is a member of parliament, not some old guy holding court at the barber shop.  In this case, the barber’s chair happened to be attached to a microphone.  That’s the upside of being an MP, and also the downside.

In Some old farts are more dangerous than others Wickens also takes Cosh to task for glossing over the fact that Spencer is an MP.

Yes, Cosh was right that Peter McKay’s statements were fatuous and self serving.  Big hairy deal… what politician doesn’t spout that sort of crap occasionally?   Other than that, though, Cosh gets it dead wrong.  Differing views on personal and economic liberty are the reason we have political parties.  Differing views on personal morality are the reason we have different religions.  Larry Spencer’s views on the legality of homosexuality are not a reasonable or legitimate subject for political debate, even if he has only figured out "last week" that homosexuality is a matter of nature, and not nurture.  The fact that he’s old doesn’t forgive his expression of an offensive viewpoint (to most Canadians) in a public forum.

You’re working too hard to be contrarian on this one, Cosh.

Changes in the Indian Economy

by alec on November 29, 2003

More and More, Made in India, from GigaOm: Om Malik’s Broadband Blog.  Five years ago I wrote a letter to the editor of the Seattle Times pointing out that if the US wanted to remain competitive in the software business it was going to have to have a labour force to do that.  The issue at the time was protectionism (when is the issue in Congress ever anything but protectionism?), with various pols in a flap over H1B Visas being granted to Indians to come and work in the US.  There are only two ways to get that labour force — home grow it, or import it.  They did exactly the wrong thing and sent some of the brightest of the software industry’s workforce home to India.  And in the process, they accelerated a cycle of Indian entrepreneurs turning to the homeland to produce new products to sell on the global stage. 

Alec on LinkedIn Alec on Twitter Alec on Facebook Calliflower on Youtube RSS Feed Contact me